Skip to content

Painful Truths

Thursday, 26 April 2012

It is hard to believe that my children and I came into a world with an independent Jewish State, knowing that my parents and their parents did not. Though her safety has been threatened numerous times during my lifetime, there has always been the reality of her existence. As a travel destination, a spiritual inspiration, and, God-forbid, a potential landing place should we ever find ourselves on the run like generations before us.

We turn towards Israel in prayer. Our daily liturgy speaks of Israel’s continued well-being. And our poets, both Biblical and contemporary, speak to the yearning we have felt for thousands of generations.

No where are these yearnings and our national assertion of a sovereign Homeland in Israel better articulated than in our anthem, Hatikvah “The Hope.” I am moved beyond words each time I hear it.

And yet…

I cannot be honest about my desire for a lasting peace in Israel with equal rights given to all citizens without acknowledging that this anthem is problematic. How can an Arab Israeli speak of a “Jewish soul” and “Zion”?

Neshama Carlebach, who is a gifted musician, an advocate for peace, and my friend, has embarked on a path that is both righteous and, for me, painful. She has recorded an alternate version of our people’s anthem with inclusive language. Intellectually, I know that this is a necessary dialogue if there is ever to be true peace. In my soul, the words feel as though they are being forced into spaces that are a different shape and size. I have listened to it over and over again. As shimmering as Neshama’s voice is, I become no more accustomed to the new words, or their implicit and explicit meanings, no matter how many times I hear it. And yet I know that such change must be an inevitability. As counter-intuitive and uncomfortable it is.

And maybe that is ultimately what our Hope is; it’s not enough to be free in our sovereign Homeland. We have to create a place that models our values and the teachings of all that is good and right. Which is what genuine freedom is.

3 Comments leave one →
  1. Thursday, 26 April 2012 7:49 pm

    A worthy discussion to have. Sadly, many of the comments at the Forward on this were rather rancorous and anti-Palestinian… Sigh.

  2. Thursday, 26 April 2012 7:57 pm

    Such a great question! My father and I were just discussing the State of Israel this weekend. I was saying that Arabs need no fight because they will ultimately out-produce Jews in 20 years.

    Something is going to have to change.

    And your point about the anthem is a good one. It is inherently anti-Palestinian. How can Israelis move forward when their anthem is so divisive?

  3. Joan Schuls permalink
    Saturday, 28 April 2012 5:55 pm

    I hope all people of all denominations can live in peace. My dream is that the Palestinians and Arabs and Jews can live happily together. They must accept the Jewish Existence. Freedom for all . Amen.

What's On Your Mind??

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: